[dns-operations] Karl Auerbach on adding 'millions' more TLD - what do folks think about the operational impact?

Paul Vixie paul at vix.com
Tue Jan 9 00:45:18 UTC 2007


> > http://www.circleid.com/posts/internet_zombies/
> 
> If there are millions of TLDs, it's no longer so easy to run a root
> service instance.  Especially if the change rate is close to what we
> see today in .COM.

it's already not easy, but this change would indeed make it harder.

> Fortunately, this is not something we need to worry about because
> devaluating TLDs does not make economic sense for any of the parties
> involved.

indeed not.  when i proposed something similar in 1995, folks laughed.
i didn't know my audience and so i didn't realize that i was asking the
fox to leave his guardpost at the chicken house.  in 2001, someone said
<http://www.merit.edu/mail.archives/nanog/2001-03/msg00303.html> which
did not become funny until pretty much just this minute.  original 1995
paper is attached, since it's no longer considered too large to e-mail.
(btw, karl auerbach has commented on this paper in the past.)

-------------- next part --------------
%PDF-1.3
%??
5 0 obj
<</Length 6 0 R/Filter /FlateDecode>>
stream
x??YM???????`JD0??W?JE?dG?Xr$&?K?bI? @?V???T?O?u?>???!???0?????????W?????????_'?}??^e/????WJ???q???+?Rf????%?J?*_E???????Pvke?P??k?z??a?'?{????C_??W5???k*_?A?6p?????|???8?UG~???o???????s???? ?????z???#h/??EF????????,??Ui??`
?i??`???t?????o???e???)?Zm??h????{???y???(L??~??42?m??P????q?*:?VxE?T
?E???]c? HB?=_?????5?n?P&??~???h?f^Zt??A??hO?????a?a >L2>y?M???,??s??0??&?????y!?????OyAk?0????
???&Y?5-?0K????=???mY?t?4??@YTy]??"
nQ? V?????\kr?<sY}a>?:?x?????@>?k?y???Md?6?z???1	??)?!2??N{?(?>?j??C? ?_????f??P%^^???p??fc????X??r?C?@????n?N]{j{~K??F\A(?????y(?,?38??????]?Vd?u9P??a??????l??????F{e?6?*??D?c??84?,???!_k{??U{??L??xpnLg?"??uj?MFF?6??i$R?
??????!?F??r`??,??l?A?\\??f?I?K*
c?F?3\?S????g??FDvt?x?t7??????1????P?'?*??6?X????^~C?!????????????Z?w??:??PQ?C?:VM>?;F?oa???bGE? ???~??^????u@?o?s\0????F?$?g?5??{??u??7w??+???
?t???? ??5?D9?\p?#`W?0?Dx`+A5?????k;0??(~!???ZsK? ?lI{#??k?R??0??P??Q?S???1?jV ??YC[?5-?xo/?b???/TF??j??X&?????j???Q?NXN!wL4?????	???B??{??j????Wk(?(???}??????)j??L?}oQ??^|???????$?R??C????gk?$???o????OF?[c? ??/???????q?r$?3pQ???6V@?d?H)?cU?4?	"bt<????F??\???q:??8?8??Z{???1??>XU????9y??w??\G???&??UQ???H%?Uv'???	b?????I? ??
?2?K???A|??? ?n;?}??r??U57]>??#?B!$?v??9S??'{?~I???u?",}??	 ,?V}~s??F???W?z-n?????+?h:n?as??p?}??? S-??0 ?o????????p`WB?????8???w?A3???Wo?o??w?{R4? ?
AGv??<?h???N??%+.G?B????]??D????? p	J??7{?F?????fy?e??Qi??Y?h?3C?r?U?B????PkM?3?T*O??Tb?7IeI????'#"???*??PK?^$?^?????s??RO?!?%|-bO!??W/,v??o?e????6?\N??v'x?9}?F??_+???A{??l6??/?*o?Oj&???k?? ?j???????(????O??BV??$'??4?p?(C9?M??m??X??$I??/??	U?J???x:??w@??]eK??J?
?Fs???g??@?#'???t=*n[`?)9????*'R??
?yK??j7Q8??J?e9L?UV???Y???????(
?!????\?B?1?-??w??????) p`?Z??????
/+?N{2?QN*?3????n	??u??F????.]???4??u?}y?;X???????/?TT??i???g??\a8y&?????,?q?	6???w??V?g?u??P?? ??,??\???6F???i~D??*?oS???&O?#/I?????????7??}??+{?m???DlcF????*???"????XZ?x??Yha???p??_???D??:??UFs???-???I"??`???b?-B.e+??Q?P5?j??$t(?E%?O`?(H??[T!"?+~??`??p???????~2??g???????e.
??B?
?W??C???+@?t?m?U6O???/h????a3V>?4???????)|?m[?$w????y\3?????????\?|*??#???j???d[D<w+E"& ??h??}@/?K?A(?H?Ae??B?@?O>?0?9b?????^?A?M[??4e ??`?q???????l? )W?? ??iM]MC??+?@\!??l????Ky|!c???U|??,????.?s6?=U{?)W
??5??X*?djHm??????Q?#?u??????VXj??+??HK?i??=?i??(?*l ?^?$?q??8u??X?>?	v???????_??4??4??c`'m???|??????[??
??u??tNdR??M?-wv???ySpr&RjUf????q?o$???,?pfsm??????????/w?/??E?%??m??????>?8???IG???I?8?????]?2??R?C?NX?Y?e?vt?<U??(??|?D?????????{??ll?g??????bQut?NF???Tq?r?X??Z?JM{??$Rl??=CE???R?X>???? W(2kv?
}?W?t{?Hd???? V_??)??,?+?eLz	_??????=?????w#???L?R?t?m?0??K??BC="??D???$P?'os??dn???X???
??j?I-??}S},?-?>5o???D??o?~mp7u??F???????_|?H????Q????v?P??h' ?FpiDp<?r_?? ? m????m?\z4??l???V7???????&"?D?(????,A?~6C~?!??8??> ??"1??ZeP??????o?R?v?8(?_??	???H???+??????q?F~??i??Q??s24h?mZ?K???aWZ"!?_$?:?b???=??????]?/*??U?T?94??R?dvph?t>sEJ?? ?e0?Z7?$?l??O?:????DyQ??h)%??????u??????J!#?N????)k??B(NS????@?
D?????2??%Y?y????Q??~?UCc??S?U?o?C=7?????j	?r?m??T0?Pg?N??Z??X??O=??er????P?????@??t?
???T??D>?h4??~_??+?m????????9?U2???`????_???]|
-'?!]|L???-'???Y?????K?q??P?3Khl??A??W	????,???h?	????GY???@j?*
g9??@???9?,???$?Z??uS?!A\?w? ??2Z????b?Jix9????|{???BCendstream
endobj
6 0 obj
3651
endobj
15 0 obj
<</Length 16 0 R/Filter /FlateDecode>>
stream
x??[?r?X???+?38a?p/?5+W???:\v??/?Y?$D?L, ???WW?_?9?/??'&bBAx?G>N?????_?+???????w&?????????f???gF???????ox?????a?{??`i??????Y??u????yu???a???ox?xo?C??2H??Y?h??(?
>???n????$????KX??^?73y???}?w.?J?"?/???????????FI??@??&?w???7}????z7~????e|uM??l?y???o???U?????Sb???^{,???e???m?,?c???-???L?dd??I?{>????N?u??? C?#??ea????????N?D??yYa?$5?i???[7E??@??1??Eg??W4?????"?(>ce???]Q6?N???m??r???6?m?9??zu???u;?????-VY?????3=??_?OJ???(??p?z7??L???k??e??e??w??m?u{12???L?#}???[AF?????uW???????
f?c?OmW???[?'?_d?l?K?[?c1??.?V??"h???c*???[?-????lJwv?&???cR'w??_??&?v?????`KD?01??Wi:?xH????0|???{?? ??;???+?VE??V6B??jo???????#U?z?<qb????[?
U;x?<?^E}'?W7????e???;D??3???^?#Y?b??????0??pd?}0
p?z?|A3"0???	?????6]Qm?j=?%?,?? J?c??!????UG/??Z?m?yl&?>??Kd!#{????gh"v?'T?,?0|?*??????[???Y??r?9??]???	|???"??*?*A?% Y?)???,??q?._??Z?ta????????????V??A,nq*??????SJ???~??B????A?&N??f???a?*B??X??_?IP]w???????P??????s???MK=?0?????s
????a_2?&?r?Hh?`??ht?M-?1P?????3??M?????f^Q??9_??X???h??R???E??W?j??5???aSG??nv/w???$??!?%?6?????????p?????H??.??0???+???w??@>?y?&?????^??F>??C??????ch??????w????-?
??[???0[fj?v?r?cS??+??E??;?J????E?Bx????Z??L?Vc?	???>"?[?5 ?z'<??t,??A?????{?>|?? ?m?d??0J????u???=2???,?*$>Za?|&/Me?J??8??
??i???g4?|-V???M?7???????W?\<8
?6???S??H!?v??#XY{sRA7??!??Z???3?^G?I?7????W????7r6R$Q#??~?C??qm??????>	?&?R"iY?H???2?h??j???D?(???i??0?U?a??dUQl?41
k?
A?xr?R???9J}r???????kW??.'F?fb?,m<?????\H???&?W#??.?v?	??c:)??VDg?xU????\0(?j?1r??P??w?%??,B??B??~??P?P?MS???o?? v?G@?N????? ??3?k}b???=HZ???9Un???x)?Z????y@??iBrA?	qm????efa??NC? ?M'?	$t????
?$H????^????Db
???a??0K'V???????#?????4??<? ???????X7????)?W??9)??w??MZ,???k?Re~-???Dg^??M????? ???|'a?????u?'m??'!????0P
?w??-?gD2??.?????]?v?Tu?X=!??fc?-?>??????,w?8???$ ??.
?5??H?-?#Z8????pY??D
?j??m]????F?>C?p?a]&??Rc??i??h???{b-?X??&T?l?u?)?o?????W?n????e?Srdv???s???dP?"?g???S??u??(?	`??????[???	N?p,???g????.|?8????1Cu??????Y?@??-?3?E????5??FBn?0q(?J.}?? `-??????E??2?,I?4??A?? ?{}F?eDL?n?M???,)?8??za??	???q?P?9?? 4??<?[?z???
']?dk?Y??y&h$I???(??t? ? ??Sp3?? ???i8?kv??m?>I??x?1????C?2?s?]??<Q??g?(]?0??{y??D??.U?u??xF?g?q,??C?t?O??
0?????Vl???$??p	??k?su_???Sf	?T????B?}???|???,L??b3r?U	??C?ra?)?k?&?3?X??q^??d?P?D??M'v?oF\??j??4?Y??????8?hR?`K?)??t??9?N?/??^?>D]???????%?;???Ht??mS??Mdp?nGN?e??f?????KR9x?e??/??X?g???[N??????1?	????f	????u?9R;
?j5?a?1q7~????7?N?+l??????%P;a?(S?
?? X9?1?Z??????0???a=?!t~???i?t?%???????OBu??+? {dj6tI??3?????_?*???b?X[x^????c????;$&??k{?Ig
?P???s???FIx??1Hs?=??7?Kl??J??????'J?L?a=@aMDd?:?????M?oW?u??u??J?\l??%4?&???????4o??N??$?6??`{C?jBY:??	C??`??2K6?$g~5???/@?P?+??H???QS??Ue?A?bxv8????????D??]??C?\???
?Y??VV?f	?H#?#????4<??(~P?+???)u????H?87?U??@???????????<)???????
??????qT?????PM??,pJA"??e?z?????.???.,??at????H??Vm????
?&????+&?/??C<?H?????R?S~k?]?]?u?2?Uu&?????)??G???8??7??
&zz2;???V??+p?1?:???9?|??
???????]?? pp??9???R??????9V??:?D?6
?_??????$????p?\?MWN(0Q?l?i??\es*&nY?\Z?%W?? ??5?i?)?T?/?h?????h?dni??Y??_?Ot?/?
???4wL??)%b?w;ui????G?u?M?9??????????p?K??E?VD?:?-??l]6?{???S??????'??@??????B?}?'??wlg?()?L??T?d]m???#?>SD.?d??9L~?%qtM??+??c?????}?Y# ?NB?9????l???"??I???K????u?M?PAf"??O?^?wm??? ?? R|?{??????????????????^?A|???8)????F??r5?\??{??\??Qm^??H_?9f ?c??lD9F?????5#?X??B?]D5??K????t?I?
&?5-??f??F+3?y at 1$?0??'w???)??"??????zeL?V?M6??????T?83???]?N??A?8?U????c??W8?????x??r%?O?}U9??[???i?od2Y6?N????!o??g?T7??s <?Z??4????0F??'?`?>}?:_?f9????????$}f??]?}??v??|S?e???????^YGH? ?Q?
??????U1}??m?8?y?8?s?????IMs?I??????(@?}y?c	)Q???H inO{%??Y\?k???R??J????]??yd???I???l?{S??I??p?a+??\oM6k?Z???qd$mJ??6???I>?S8zs?NMA????
???V?I!???u~?7???????e?W???????^V3?!?0D9??#?(?}?`???<?_??G(1???Vx???M?A??P,5!?X?!??r? ??u?@e?}??"9/iYMq?i-?/[????ZD?>?$E?a?????T??a???@?{W???%?`???Z????U	?a?C??^? ?r??\??!?46<7 Ix??ji?/?=?? 
N????8?e????r>c!?&???O6J?N?)??4|??K
6??I??aU?z?klm??w?i'?/=?}?
??????Q?#????%e?-^??7]2&?????L5z?-??????{0`?Eu?CX????
?4??????0Y =?	E?`5O???]?^Z?	?Eo?:??????gRpY??G??lA?5?,?;?Hk??W????Ns?9?A??@??e??Sk?D?? (.e\+@???H????c??R?T?.n8r??? ??Q'd)e??%O&??:d[/??;32W[??2?????x??9??=????Jq4??,6f?)??[?Sg???yw?O ???????v???GY???W4v??????e??Lr????F	?>????????Z?u+??Lsl??(?cS?j?Pu?-?m?????3s?\?E?M?a??"??e???5?#R@?7y Pwz,$???DY?rX?v?y???d????'????.????T7?F	?gz?+?-?D?l?'?"???K???
_Uu7?+?HO at M??
?p-M_?5+T?&?$5:9?L??m?????Vr?????cL?j???1??`?Q???o????P???ss<y|?rf? w?/d	??`???$J6R3???T??'?''f????Sw????SU??6? `?/[??c??m?j?&??=?drl????+p?.mXv???!AJ%??b]eo??j?e???wM??I\.?H}?x<???Y?/?6zc#g???c?u???3ne??????2l?
gV;?NF;?{??????'??V?f???p???[??9??W????@??c?C`9????"???7dN?????^?D?Ih??S?RM`????? Y?5???<??9???d??._??;?w??CE!????o?_??????B??x????????igGC(????h?3?????K??s???P??21??;?? E??V?|?????
=
?f~yP(???T"??w?!!?y,???c5{t??rVu?{?(-?[|]Y???Q????8?I?I???0????H\??r#?
???Ssn]f?=??????? ?K^endstream
endobj
16 0 obj
5550
endobj
21 0 obj
<</Length 22 0 R/Filter /FlateDecode>>
stream
x??Z?r?F?}?W?m?
?U???Qc{?[?=?k?n?

?p1?y??oo??, ?lQ
?h??Y?'Of??????O?n????u??W???O??C????+#??g{x??[jo????1?????!o?~???l?n|G???L??]a????&?Q=?9??o????????q3????__????????$???P
?r??&???F?UC???9??}75;<??w??b?wM%-?om4?7???j^??a????MbR?,?wU;??O?+N?????8????&?E??o?v??????&???WI??Vlb?	AU?cg?5?z'??]????H?????M??????k|???}?????U?x?e??}(?????-r?"L?-lG????E?!???sZ??H;?q??F??Y?t????5o}?p??n?6*[? ?<=?~??/1???~:?m=>?>?;Lfc??jH??4???p{?A??D??%??<???????i?
?g9????&f???&???8?????,0H?FwWV?z ?"09?*??}5??8KC??Ma?q?z?????UT????P~|S?q??^E???????q?H?c?	?V?{RH????X?c?n+?0???ZR????k?=K???X?G??
?????>??,?>??b?V???*?????0+
?Ly-?.s???L?
i??E??r??kh??h?-?l?H?Q?{)
?xX?p?u.??2??}?D??&.zd???t=??&8?2p??"K?OW???&?R?=K6:c??X???+???N`???????@}?6???neigk??/??.???N(??3A ??liSI?FS????Wt?)??B???ZnA*?X
?T??u????)?@???-q&>??????t?#?=\??e???}??S??H-?}M?N???ab?W?`F?9???-????\????f&???fN6??}??t?	
S??c
I?????U?????7?Q????t?j?X????}????$6????? ?*??~jw????p?V?S?g???^?|??????9Zp?\?~*K6(6?g?A??-?\?T\f???K3?
1??v?=?C??????pCB???i
U?
?????n???{H???l??s+%#,?????c??????e??V???<]??.???z????:?/Ox???^R????e????T?C/k??(%qfDn???-}HMi??Id??v[???X???4??C??8z???7W:A????K?&? -??s+\??R??M2??n?|???????d3Y??m]??|??">:d????t7&?7	?[?a??dg?l??Nw@ ?2j?a?(h	3?<?X?5??|??a?4
?L??f??@k??
|????E`??&?w?x:wv??j??W	)a?W??|????
'l_p??f????H?w??????O5yw??	?w?F;?h????P????<?2???huUC??????0????3E??j??T##h???L??sH??W?
/?u??&?? }4?f?m`??-bi?L\?m??E?*q??C5?U8?Aw??lY?(!?k?7???t??5?Y???E;???Xq?U?v??~E?V?QX	???L.??f??7??)|
G?????U??~`?D?W??'?d?
T????A?.?*??P??QI???????i??z?Hh-	?@????
???lj??h?????p?>?6@(??o.???;0&zJV~?|?9????" ??? 
@0U??:?f????AR(j-JM???ihsH?????rOd?E?????V??e?]???\??[??I>?Q????D?c?"??u`L????Kd??H{B?ar%?_??d??N??;Z@?i??5?
??tX-?NL0?}N??MZ?;	?F?p?????n?n??E4??'?l???Y??
?&?)?g?w?????N,????BMh???????????q?J?B ?H??e???A[M???V??}&Se3-??C?v-???]??}??QC?Qi8?Zi???l??0??y???v8CLC??c{5??2???@?D??I?A?C?i??P??Y??yN??:d?$??s:?????|cR]???	?????/t^????;?G
?P(Nq?2?V?????Q?K.?B?????BcI?m?Q)s
v???????I?;0W?Vw?J??Lv?g?LZ-???@?&??%???C	??A??u?H;??.??M??
?????????j??@a???
(??<?[?{Y??v???s?`0?b?????Dv???	???@K"d\??,'???	?$e?^b?s?U?F??9J?e4??b?>{?U?T]Q????9
u?,???cG8?:??WB?? $Y $?R	?OY?N??A?0t?J2&????9
?*?,???? =??d????G????T????
??A0?y??d???:??)?/??Q"r?v??$QS??????	????@?I?	?f??u??M?e?{???^#)?Ef0?
???.k????;F?MQP?2rn??im?<'zpKE?K?$<CV??G?p?????v??c???9L???,?	?vW?r!??_Q?q?{~??P?fY?bF?D?7????;??2?v?u?$?-??E?Ge??m????jWo%????9?Y???p????yc??f??]v?]s?k????iXZh?{??Bkg"?mL?	?<??T?$??M?[?&???'?=??? e??i?{??x>??%?????g(\?
	??L??n?.?"?)	?5LY??"?3??i?M
W?&5?????
X?l&???A?&?<?@?El?bA???R(?)8?B`Uo???
????U??{?&???w^?s?=?f???I??C?/xKa????`??*?"W???????*k?z?p??G	?k?T?>??M?)?????A*?%??????bf?E?GD~|U?At??????Ua=?$I5?uY?g??E?B?5??nC4??o?????H?	???W??O?7+??6??t????<?????????n??*?-q?;?Fb%??H?dQ???p?_*M9??@,)#K?EI??
?M?_3?1q??S???????8F,CLz7!&(?L??0??g????X?82"8?C??d????\"BT?]P?9??>GS}Q?rQ?w???m28!??]?r??YW
r?:?&?????87>?<\.?
<?BZ%???4??:m?????QFQ??c????B??(fg?P7?'rtZ?wz?sYD??<}???x?*??IZ??20^8-????)????d??a4?Rm?'?'?<?o?A??8??G=??~`B?Q?3?p?=sj?'d???Q?fr?i?o?????P??;?\? j??V?Rx??0??? ???G?G?R??f?G?I?,j???????Z?cH???M??;???A????{;??/??WY??"???W`???I_uF|???Z%?9?@???C???T??v-???t|?r7????(? ??y|'?K=?#	6f???<~??sRz??	Y?p
%6?B~!i"^I??P?z??f
?y?sg?EtY?Z??hi?z?O!D34??W?\)=PW???Iq	?'?8Lm?i????'/????s?P??S?q???JC}8?#??ShtrN?[??0?o4???Q??N?!?c????RRh??.9?????*?RG??q?9?E???f#???_????~????????K?~??@??)5?X3?tq}??????m??A??t`v?e?~U1?!>\????lF?D36e?0Q????????]V?B??????K0M5h???]?P???#?@?F?X?526*h??R/??????JI?DO?O~+?['?U??J????C??*??R`??P???????Z?'y?1?S?????$?z??o????\hl??`??6][i?L??[ D?V?r?]??Y??????x??#?C???k??xa?=??t??=??????IAW???p^?LoX?
??"?? _??=t=????2???????GW}?j)???
 ?p]?ktc?uH?K?<$.y???A$d4U?Sq??|?E???mHQ?u%![B??(E?4?[]`a?Ea?*,>K? ?h??}f$e;r~?i!?\X?p???U?N?>??(?d???:i?F6,?3W5???l=J@??D?y!???1U?????s^?9??(??M=?????/???ABm??6?g?r]?]I?t?R??z+G???t@?&??'~????	??F?n(hy?,??4a8?[_Sp??/wu?????????m??D[?6?fp? ?????=??Z?????HClA??e8[?*\N??Z??Z?4?o???@?m??$????z?"??+!@7)s??B%??jn?+J?Ya.??SIB??P*?"??@'?H3??????cy??{?
?;?????w?y???Reh???H???,??	?G?u???N?9/??a??S|??<????{FD?1'$?J??????(b?tIr?t????Tm??P??z??+???%??????h??W??o?GN??u? ??\?B?h??[V
o?of?Z????&$??Q??rWC??:q?????
???????/W????(?
;?j?S?XRd1Z?Is???3A})???3?d?V??u"p-?!]J?\?u?gD?+??P;??f
??%*X??!f??7???????Bx:)?H6?n?Ck~?????(???u&h??*!??	T\?%??B??F/`??>TYU???y%??DJI??????_????7''endstream
endobj
22 0 obj
5031
endobj
27 0 obj
<</Length 28 0 R/Filter /FlateDecode>>
stream
x??[Is????W??*cR?x???v??%??s?s g@,00???J?O?????J??`yK/_???S???'?7???]???9??W???????????/7?|@Wn?Nx??4Q?Q????f???:???wW?????V?]?~????i????o??#?8P?-??f{??|?fu??h?6??\????&??]u,??Y{?]?9??Z???????iQ<?? ?v????>|?N`?@??m?:b?`????x?h?:	????(X?&?R|2????gr&-???????x?J
"?~E???????i?W%l'???????????y????\\?'7?u?2|"?Y?Ah`?J?#??t?Vr8????D???N???WoW:X????e????^??z(?:?{\???nC$?0?e?+l??s?Ree(?????Ev?V??R?????o?/??UD??????C?O?2AE?hd2mu?/?+??G?+h?(?m?OsZ??r??}?w?
|^U?ielMC???????????1??!0!l?>?????%??D?+???M^fM#6o??f+4?W???]a??$)6????Z?~???l?5?%<?{M???|???????0x?????
hb??nG?A?i???!/
??.??;?] Dm???
O??a?R7???Yg?.ICZ?i;??u?,?*?s?,???$?}???,?l?Y??gi????u?\?.?*????|???(T%?s???H????K?k=?,
?F?v?U????1??? `4?|??c?x?+?7????-~???????w4dLk?????2?????m?r??????T?s??e$?y?mz	???ni*???B^x??r( ??d??hM AE?6d?
J???{?RE??/?&????lbW????0?^F_u?k??E\	Qn  re??/??oA???;?_??U??!$???9?[??G?S???Gk??S?!?O?%G LI? Pq?
???RD?,K??8A??9 m?????P	a? ?,.?D??#?!?(?#????~? ?ek?)??*?[9??J?Z?}?0?4r?^z-? YB???C?87?B?6>[qS0????@???	? P?#???N/K7?"?;[J?Nmp1{#b??O??s?????t?_#?C?\??U?2??0ot?TD2|???Y?0??@f??C#???=?8?3?c?v??/B???i!3k?p"P?? 
?86???awlo?????L??,xP??r??,gC?8\??D\???u???
??3#[
	X??M?g^??V?1(A??!D??`f5??-l`X?@?(V?????6YB? ?h?CIh???v?>1x?:??E m?r?+,??p?5l???D54?t?5??D?? R?L?!???JDS`T@?7???gFf??? @???-?V?0'x??}?@??e?C??B?4^?P???u>?????6mr	 ?@B6? P?`	??@l??"Hf??`??Cqc ? dD?r????PM???DBNr???a
??$?h????8{"S<??k)?>Xk??T)z??t?	???W? ?,???-=??l??^[x??????>G?s?S/m8??UEQ??????*p??N ?` ???????
f|???m??? ??1????A???? ?????l?'?(???_a4 ?CZ?0??I??ZV???D????8JJ? ?)6???????^??.?A???Fa????4rt?S??n?i??|N?????C;cV??eR??@q!0H2J?Sal?$(?????$*??D?%??D???3? D?n??X???@?083L?t,?<C???MU?d??0???c<-?*???, ~?)??????????#q?K??YfR?HB?3????N.@AB???k?5 ????1? ??Ar0c\???????cG??"??????{ ?D%t?????D????w?M???; ??n3}?)?w?????????]~;}??????????"?????Y0???s+x{q?l??w?]}3?y<0?3?\???E?)?`9 ?
'?????H??JS?1y???z??j????
x??@f???x?^????x??	#R?[???rEf???xH???>);?a????n??q7q(?X????M???????|R???M???h??*?W??gx?#??"?G?I!p?!V?@Z9{?w??&^J?%??s??r?\k???
??:??,,tw???q?"v?w?w?+o?5?v?/?!?~??_?PJ ?X?j&J- ???'_?M????{???/p?>?"u%?h]?w???@?O?G?*+T???'K?&??dz?QE?'a?RT?2????%?L?|? ?E?5??????+???h??|????H?'|?2'???S?c!?8>
?s?e??2.??9?2?#f???p?X?%?\l?@f??1] ??[???+1}e at 0????+d????,???1x???}?'l?g??b??|?kPV-?^l D?#?V?H?PQ?v?1?v`#?j?Rg?Z???6#?6?j???,?a??.%?QX??6?
?>???|C02`'9ZD-Q$????,? ]=?"?z?O?
???U?f?`??_??`P?!X???$'??????0??g?+?Q+??? _??-U?P?w???=?rs????????4?HGBE???????;?q2??@??o???S??H?6?n?(l0??>?xrtN\???5H??\????(???L?a]O?h???Ui??y?JR????K VR?N?{?uP???1???F???=?P
k??"Wg?=C~}??]J???ZLT???O?]o?????e?y{l%???T??d??A????(F?>?`???Z1?.?|??<(?dG???U$?b??UQ??ek??X??? ?	O&[?9l????"c???q#????h$U?+???>?u??}?;?2??8X?? U???z,?Q?1??c?4T??UOM9~f?|??:??:@?l???(d?Z?.?_????"??????????Z{??jF????hw?7??4??&O???w&??nV?6??WM??	5I??O?8??3J???^??z?O??iGD??+?0=#??)????~c??m?u?B??8?H7???
3???? W?7?????k???????D??l??6??*?*??< lbc?(?`??Gp????????Hfay?.?
-J?1d?4????V?*?3-???f???`?A???1#)L N??6V?*S^?u?3?????/??r?MG?????T????tB?`?f
#X%?
@??"hu?x=/?1I?+?M?J????"X?#U??($j??@r?W??'?HU?A??d??
??`g?????Mtd$;?KN5?%?U??????3D.i??~?z??)5?,?0q?_j?qs?B????W??k?9e?:;?OS???&?(?D|??EK??????????dZ?}?(?N
?~_5?/?3_I??4mX??l?;?? ?'
?
+??F.??mP??U?x?V??(?? ??mV???A????m?oDD:%7?~h??0?
a??@,? ?Y??
Y??
?	6_???>??r0
2?a?kP7?2w.?m?A)?a?G?Ho????]{?????J?o???[dI??T????6???{??3???P?????,:??s?s4?6?{`F???x2j?JS[n%???/??"??
??:???vO'??'??bn?-??#i?w?/E%?z?mvU??g?R??EQQw/?
?ti??.Fp? L?,???97??>?+??%>9?e?H?~?t??k???oz?A?)o??g4???*?T??0I?*?Lj??`???g???m(OT??v??f,/???
??-?<G? ????]q o#?AA?X???#??E??%x?q&V??h/??Y:?????6&<Z2?????r/	??S????_???7????%5?sB-? qz??'?zi%??0????r??k@?l7rFUu??z????q?
d=???A?By5???+?]q??(???1????#??q?a0???jw??2?XvR#?2o_?s`3??1??y? R? 8??P?$u??@?K?fu8i??1??3g?F(u????ur??K2?%?p?????aYy??????Z?|EK???0?7?i#?'R,[?E??#?"?? ??
5\???,w?n`????.???A?
3"??a3??USJ??bQr?E????(?6?\???d;?;?o?L?V????7?|)???(S??#?@??????GV?Q}?l??e???@G?D?2#?t?lp?N?Bwt???6{?-?*?O?h?cWKh0?*??????f=6)p ?????	l???Iz?R?'-??# d??cP0?$???@??Ue????4?~??V????tYD?LwCH? o???m^?????WJA?N9??m_?c?Oq)???
?????r?JF0!e??`???h?|???H?? ??m???H?zJa)+??,:NN?,? _??,??m%?mu?E??]Q??75`hi??a[g?m'???or[??-q'GFu?,?????KTN??#?????????????=?????S??0?>???????3??;???S??&?5?!?^7'????.??endstream
endobj
28 0 obj
4980
endobj
33 0 obj
<</Length 34 0 R/Filter /FlateDecode>>
stream
x??ZMs?F??W????`03???vRJ?r??S?Ur?HP?????m??}?= AP??=m?*????~???L?8?B}???w?>???q???	?>}????q??????O?q??Z????O??4?C^?O??	]?\??M?m?y?bc? ??(J?z_lm???4X????;?????o??YhG?su??Q??L????
5/?LuUS?W???U?;z?j]??h???i???j??]F?q??YSC?0q????7??)F????c5?V??TW??V}????9+z}[u0?
?Z?9?yf?$av:?>?uj'?L<'?}?Z?W?????bh?????@?a?&Z??P^??[??d??kv??6?8?U??9??n?)??s???%;?>	Ew????u@#m?g???4V??ET?
K?Y??0A?g?m??y?\Um????&?fK^4??]~?6=\cIc:F??????
$?v??Mq#?eMXC\?c?cmTUj:?O??9?%?G?*?????????}Yld? ?3?
?}l?w??]???g??????(?Y?????[H(?Z?=8?4|?.??h?????fV???e?vc?-G?u???v?g?q??h?Vv???o???_.V]s???>????jB??A?d??v4?*}L?g?d??lJ?"M??2\pn??E???l?l??l?V;??`?J?Gc^??????g ?-g??A>????|?V?R?>p~xt{?O?9J?>????????B?G?
??>?#?:??@C9	?	?>?????????????^??.??M?$	?L/-??y?<??0???cG:??B?.?{=?
??%????A??)??A??r??S?P??k?c?C?w?????J|x??????W:?????fW?_???0??78>s?4??/_?????T?W??N??0????????#_??~>JO	??k,?xy?E?^??????$:i??~??Ql?/?qh|??Y?????^$??#(E1?e???????F???m???ax?-???y?DF-?????=???9???U5?%IY(JRVK?\?+1??m at t?c?BH??XXb#{???
??/219/???i??[?	?q??09?Y?
=5?(D?&?d??cEWzv?F=;?:???L?x???`5H???T??&?4???5?xo?v??$??;J-&M?Zn]?Sgy??7?4?"*!)??1?TZ( ?????I(??3J$XzJa??V????-?
?4"h?i??}p$??D?|?V??????MY????1?w|M???5R??<??`:~
6f?rs??E?L??f,V????A?d?d}?m$??J???a?| ?l?
i?l?d/??h?2m??w?m???z?;?r?l;?&&???q+?Jy?Sj	K??]?l(?4????????a??O0??P???Uw??-(?5???)V?'{r???????{???? c=/@u?yd??6F????????s&?=r??!)<????m?????F?by?M`{1???????@?u?c)??w?/?????;??c-P_???G?P-???+m_??j?8???e?
?>?*???mY??ou?d??UU?=?s?6ho??lD?{?m#l???Ly?x?x??????j5v+?!r.?.?Tvj???"???a^J?&w??f?B???b?????@?L???NME7??.9??"????%?Kz?v??w?????,???]J???S?W?l?T???G??MOJr(?/1aJ	g??dx?s??W??}\???=??.?i?tD?KF?Aa???1}?e?k????R??v)?\?Q?8??Vj?E??wm???7`?A??>A??p?????? z?,?|/?n?&|?_d??
?-?[???J`???G???????R?y4????? ??6<;?k???^N???T_????M???/'??y??|tr ]l&?E?? ?YuI;;?U??????U??/Y?f????????$e?l??UZ?4I?vT-?E??xY<??ct:?"??O??p????>??>^P???mD%??M???	?n?Aq?	l?v????Hi?j?y?[??O?3?????U)G??????r[????h?x????+Y?8C??.????,HR?.??i?I????^wn_????2=h?<HHo8Q?4"{??(??r???>w?????????????3????9???z???O?@-?P1C??cS?(????`??M?J??S??\?LqNl??0rA???.z??????nDZ??T?M???.pL?G??%/?/?#?????Z?)?+???u?4Xp??G?i?n??????z?}	??{?IN??z??(?|)?9>[9?1 2??L???z??????r|?P??Jl?u?M???a#K??W&;>k?G*O{?di# r?e_???`ku?dq6?N????)?r????gv8?#9?GHF>@?Ww	??-?e????+?*???
a?-?????[8??@}Q?ch??j'?4(-?=?V7??}?:??Z.b/}G?w??;??k???(E[?dt????q???'-?ix?-+?zT??t??????:D??d
?????,?????21??*O??H?H?J?	9?vX?&??????~;?`?=*?????dt????$nt?tp?f?\??X??:e:??:?l$6??y??}4L:??n{??x???<X?<k??^?1????z3????????u?Xj?? ?i?J???n????^??S8?:?u|33?????:2nD?Gq?MN?
???XY?f?{@?%w?????z??7/???-???0??u??
?s???[j??u Z?G??R?,}??~Z?:I???ifdm??+?M
?+???V?F?*??<????b#??_????h??}=q?????????t<??h??.?U??J?,!?Y????-?_ ?:???d?=?m??^?E?=?^o?HMd??T??aX?{??P??q????<p?p?P)???bx}???g??^?o?
?@?x y1J?l??D???;3??*x8???Yq\Ji???PPV??SO?#???E?	?y?rn[,;B??_???W??}???r?E??U????? Y ???[?5??bV}Xng???M??`????P	?????c|?.^tSL/W???r?????G??0???b?s????C`??I?*?rA?q?s/???????!#?/0AD???9`?g?v-?F???jM1?fX?f???h????]>KA"??i*??O\J?_?it??W(#?:?T~?Qw&????iG??B??
?:??#?u>??A|?7??3?&z?_,Lr??Et??[=?\?????g???]?\	?5=
.j????E?kp??g??XM?Q?$T???????Dq?R?a=??v?|?????[bM?%?#LP}_?y`???8?+?l$t??.?G??~qq????t/?N???b?~lendstream
endobj
34 0 obj
3678
endobj
4 0 obj
<</Type/Page/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0/Parent 3 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF /Text]
/ExtGState 12 0 R
/Font 13 0 R
>>
/Contents 5 0 R
>>
endobj
14 0 obj
<</Type/Page/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0/Parent 3 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF /Text]
/ExtGState 18 0 R
/Font 19 0 R
>>
/Contents 15 0 R
>>
endobj
20 0 obj
<</Type/Page/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0/Parent 3 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF /Text]
/ExtGState 24 0 R
/Font 25 0 R
>>
/Contents 21 0 R
>>
endobj
26 0 obj
<</Type/Page/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0/Parent 3 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF /Text]
/ExtGState 30 0 R
/Font 31 0 R
>>
/Contents 27 0 R
>>
endobj
32 0 obj
<</Type/Page/MediaBox [0 0 612 792]
/Rotate 0/Parent 3 0 R
/Resources<</ProcSet[/PDF /Text]
/ExtGState 36 0 R
/Font 37 0 R
>>
/Contents 33 0 R
>>
endobj
3 0 obj
<< /Type /Pages /Kids [
4 0 R
14 0 R
20 0 R
26 0 R
32 0 R
] /Count 5
>>
endobj
1 0 obj
<</Type /Catalog /Pages 3 0 R
>>
endobj
7 0 obj
<</Type/ExtGState
/OPM 1>>endobj
12 0 obj
<</R7
7 0 R>>
endobj
13 0 obj
<</R10
10 0 R/R9
9 0 R/R8
8 0 R/R11
11 0 R>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<</Type/ExtGState
/OPM 1>>endobj
18 0 obj
<</R17
17 0 R>>
endobj
19 0 obj
<</R10
10 0 R/R8
8 0 R/R11
11 0 R>>
endobj
23 0 obj
<</Type/ExtGState
/OPM 1>>endobj
24 0 obj
<</R23
23 0 R>>
endobj
25 0 obj
<</R10
10 0 R/R9
9 0 R/R11
11 0 R>>
endobj
29 0 obj
<</Type/ExtGState
/OPM 1>>endobj
30 0 obj
<</R29
29 0 R>>
endobj
31 0 obj
<</R10
10 0 R/R11
11 0 R>>
endobj
35 0 obj
<</Type/ExtGState
/OPM 1>>endobj
36 0 obj
<</R35
35 0 R>>
endobj
37 0 obj
<</R10
10 0 R/R9
9 0 R/R8
8 0 R/R11
11 0 R>>
endobj
10 0 obj
<</BaseFont/Times-Roman/Type/Font
/Encoding 38 0 R/Subtype/Type1>>
endobj
38 0 obj
<</Type/Encoding/Differences[
133/quotedblleft/quotedblright/fi/fl/endash
139/bullet]>>
endobj
9 0 obj
<</BaseFont/Courier/Type/Font
/Subtype/Type1>>
endobj
8 0 obj
<</BaseFont/Times-Italic/Type/Font
/Encoding 39 0 R/Subtype/Type1>>
endobj
39 0 obj
<</Type/Encoding/Differences[
135/fi]>>
endobj
11 0 obj
<</BaseFont/Times-Bold/Type/Font
/Subtype/Type1>>
endobj
2 0 obj
<</Producer(ESP Ghostscript 8.15)
/CreationDate(D:20070109004339)
/ModDate(D:20070109004339)>>endobj
xref
0 40
0000000000 65535 f 
0000024262 00000 n 
0000025400 00000 n 
0000024175 00000 n 
0000023367 00000 n 
0000000015 00000 n 
0000003736 00000 n 
0000024310 00000 n 
0000025195 00000 n 
0000025133 00000 n 
0000024946 00000 n 
0000025334 00000 n 
0000024351 00000 n 
0000024381 00000 n 
0000023527 00000 n 
0000003756 00000 n 
0000009378 00000 n 
0000024442 00000 n 
0000024484 00000 n 
0000024516 00000 n 
0000023689 00000 n 
0000009399 00000 n 
0000014502 00000 n 
0000024568 00000 n 
0000024610 00000 n 
0000024642 00000 n 
0000023851 00000 n 
0000014523 00000 n 
0000019575 00000 n 
0000024694 00000 n 
0000024736 00000 n 
0000024768 00000 n 
0000024013 00000 n 
0000019596 00000 n 
0000023346 00000 n 
0000024811 00000 n 
0000024853 00000 n 
0000024885 00000 n 
0000025029 00000 n 
0000025278 00000 n 
trailer
<< /Size 40 /Root 1 0 R /Info 2 0 R
/ID [(??6?`???F\\?YS])(??6?`???F\\?YS])]
>>
startxref
25509
%%EOF


More information about the dns-operations mailing list