[dns-operations] ZSK algorithm different from DS/KSK algorithm?

Viktor Dukhovni ietf-dane at dukhovni.org
Wed Nov 15 04:23:18 UTC 2017


In reference to:

    http://dnsviz.net/d/_25._tcp.diogenes.leeuwarden.nl/WgupAQ/dnssec/

    $ dig +noall +ans +nosplit +nocl +nottl -t ds leeuwarden.nl.
    leeuwarden.nl.          DS      39529 8 2 C383F613E25AFD16DF63861932CF2BFCC70C0904E048C990022BC6B817D6B5E5

    $ dig +noall +ans +multi +rrcomment +nocl +nottl -t dnskey leeuwarden.nl.
    leeuwarden.nl.              DNSKEY  256 3 7 (
                                AwEAAabMlzUvmnHDtqiwDTNqagy/z6D5KG2D7glyCiHZ
                                9d/y0M4/70ASkWD/V2bY+SEfAXRO1gqfoq+Jb8HOu2D0
                                7F91WoZ+n4OeqGR937W/lzSL441CtnGVxFrh3iruxUYK
                                qSEXW7KlkRoa5tnlrEueU6LUpDS4jU5eo3VT70vNn4lb
                                ) ; ZSK; alg = NSEC3RSASHA1 ; key id = 20357
    leeuwarden.nl.              DNSKEY  257 3 8 (
                                AwEAAchUEsOBPcX/t/vyjrBv1n60V6zU/35BLAt45bzD
                                XTwlgh4mBTmRQ/RR6OCE1eIBcFNxRwWgfguYK3aR15i/
                                3FMyKbyf4GCc2CSdos2ex7W4f3SS6x3iODXBVfBgONul
                                ffP8woLM85yuGESIu8Wbi9okVZkR4Bhob0dUEfyVvsAh
                                o0k10RP5bDdWmKJjecfYvtKbMRNKAB2KfbNQGxwePjKz
                                Mx1ezfGmKT6toBBYI5ChPja1/rECQOq47MhrE5aFGIzL
                                0eeLu9n2wvuzGrVva7TL89kPiyZyzU7sqQk+3E0s5wlc
                                yVXW/KZlkP/O088KDJOhHzTZZgCjfrml+kFEKQM=
                                ) ; KSK; alg = RSASHA256 ; key id = 39529


Is it OK to have DS records for just algorithm 8, a KSK with algorithm 8,
but a ZSK with algorithm 7?  Unbound seems to tolerate this, though I
did earlier today see ServFail for _25._tcp.diogenes.leeuwarden.nl, that
I no longer see, so perhaps not related to the ZSK algorithm oddity...

-- 
	Viktor.





More information about the dns-operations mailing list